Friday, 17 August 2012

A basin in the hills

During the Triassic and into the Jurassic periods (Being part of the Mesozoic era) three major sedimentary basins formed in our region which are preserved today. The biggest, the one most people know about, and the youngest is the Clarence-Moreton Basin. This is a thick sequence of rocks which extends to Nymboida in the South up into southern Queensland. The Clarence-Moreton formed on top of, and with the Ipswich Basin. In southern Queensland it also begins grading into the Surat Basin.

The Ipswich Basin is smaller than the Clarence-Moreton as both basins are formally defined, but various sub-basins within the Clarence-Moreton actually formed at the same time as many of the parts of the Ipswich Basin and several units appear to conformably underlie (there is no time gap in deposition) or even inter-bed with the lower units of the Clarence-Moreton. The Ipswich Basin outcrops in a north-south line west of Murwillimbah and at Evans Head and Brooms Head. It is well known in southern Queensland for large actively mined coal deposits, it is not so well known south of the border and is often confused with being part of the Clarence-Moreton Basin.

The least known Triassic-Jurassic Sedimentary Basin is the Lorne Basin. This is further south than the Ipswich and Clarence-Moreton Basins and for the purposes of this blog will define the southern limit of the Northern Rivers. The Lorne Basin is the smallest of the three Basins. The middle of the basin is located at the village of Kew, it extends west almost to the village of Comboyne, south to Coppernook, almost to Wauchope in the North, and is present on the coast at Camden Haven and Diamond Head (Bob and Nancy have a tour of Diamond Head). The modern day Camden Haven River flows across the basin.

Unlike its contemporaries the Lorne Basin has rather poor pickings as far as coal deposits goes. This at first might be surprising given the thick units of coal formed further to the North and South at the roughly the same time as the Lorne basin was forming. In fact the coal seams found in the Lorne Basin are only of any significance in the units known as Camden Haven Group, and even then these are ‘thin coaly beds’ according to Pratt (2010) and earlier authors. What gives us a clue about the apparent absence of coal is the abundance of another rock type, conglomerate. According to Pratt (2010) there are several units of conglomerate which show that the sediments that were deposited in the basin traveled only a short distance and the river systems that transported these sediments was in a high energy environment (remember that for organic rich sediments to accumulate that will form coal the environment needs to be stable and swampy).

The clasts that make up the conglomerate in the Lorne Basin are derived from the Palaeozoic aged basement rock of the New England Orogen that surrounds the Basin. The clast composition reflects the slight variability in the New England Orogen Rock which is slightly different if the rock came from the north or the south side of the Basin. I will discuss the individual units of the Basin in future posts. But the whole picture of high energy deposition in the basin shows us that the Lorne Basin is a little unusual. It actually appears that the basin was elevated (not low lying like the Clarence-Moreton, Ipswich, Surat, Gunnedah, Sydney etc Basins) and situated in between large mountain ranges, this is known as an inter-montane basin. The well-known examples large active of inter-montane basins are in Asia in places such as Mongolia (these are much bigger than the Lorne Basin). Closer to home the McKenzie Basin near Mount Cook in New Zealand is a good example, although it is a bit smaller than the Lorne.

After the sediments had been consolidated there was a period of faulting through the Lorne Basin and during the Cenozoic era intrusions of granitic rock affected some parts of the basin and it was also partly obscured by lavas from the same era, though much of this lava has now been eroded away. The nearby Comboyne Volcano/volcanic centre was probably associated with these lavas and intrusions. Erosion of the lavas has caused a very attractive landscape including the Ellensborough Waterfall.

Since writing the above post Dylan reminded me that there is a theory that the Lorne Basin was initially formed during a meteorite impact (See comments below). I'll have to dig up some literature and discuss why this might be the case, however, for the time being it is worth noting that according to Tonkin (1998) the overall shape of the basin is very similar to other impact structures around the world. As Dylan points out: we have yet more unanswered questions!

References/bibliography:

Pratt, G.W. 2010. A Revised Stratigraphy for the Lorne Basin, NSW. NSW Geological Survey Quarterly Notes.
Tonkin, P.C. 1998. Lorne Basin, New South Wales: Evidence for a possible impact origin? Australian Journal of Earth Sciences. V45.

Monday, 13 August 2012

Northern Rivers Geology Blog Update #1

I've been surprised about the success of this blog. I set out to put little facts that I knew about the geology of our region so that others who might be interested could pick these up. It has almost been a year of posting and in the last two days the blog had its 10 000th page view. Now, admittedly about 10% of the page views appear to be bots, but there is a greater than 90% chance that visitor number ten thousand was a person.

The most popular posts have been:
1. Why you wont find CSG here
2. Mythical Geology at the mouth of the Tweed River
3. The 'older' rhyolite in the north east
4. Mining and the Bible
5. Geology in the air

The biggest referrers have been:
1. Google
2. Wikipedia
3. Clarence Valley Today (blog)
4. New England Australia (blog)
5. Look and See New England (blog)

Thanks to all my followers for encouraging me with the blog. I hope that everyone continues to find something of interest here. I'll keep adding posts on about a weekly basis... I've got heaps of topics in mind so at this rate there should be another year (or two) worth of stuff before I start slowing down. Who would have thought how much geological diversity and how many natural features there are in the Northern Rivers.

Sorry to those of you from the highlands in the New England area and those from Coffs Harbour and further south, I've neglected the headwaters of the northern rivers and the southern areas but I'll look to fixing these oversights in the coming months. Feel free to leave your comments or ask questions if you wish.

Wednesday, 1 August 2012

A magma chamber under Cabarita Beach

Again and again, I am amazed at how little we know about what is under our feet. It often takes an unexpected source of information to reveal some incredible knowledge of our region. The lastest information that has recently come to hand has been the preliminary geophysical survey results for the Grafton to Tenterfield survey. There are many results that may indicate some strange goings on, from some inconsistent features in the Mount Warning area (possibly indicating that the Tweed Shield Volcano might actually be a myth! More of this in a future post or two), to strange lineaments and responses showing hidden intrusions. This post is about just such a possible hidden intrusion in the Cabarita area.

Smith (1999), curiously reported that within the Neranleigh-Fernvale Beds at Norries Head, Cabarita (located on the coast midway between Tweed Heads and Mullumbimby) there appeared to be evidence of thermal metamorphism in the rocks there, but no evidence of what caused the heating. Metamorphism is a characteristic of the Neranleigh-Fernvale Beds, but the style of metamorphism is pressure related due to the formation being accreted (squashed) onto the Australian continent during a period of subduction during the Palaeozoic period. Not much heat was generated in this formation and based on the minerals identified in the rocks it is possible to estimate the pressure and temperature when these rocks were squashed. The feature that Smith (1999) identified was biotite crystallisation (a variety of the mica mineral group). This mineral is indicative of heating of rocks to a medium to high grade but the lack of a preferred orientation of this platy shaped mineral shows us that the metamorphism postdates the accretion period. ie. the heating of the rock has occurred some time after the pressure, meaning at least two periods of metamorphism.

As discussed in a previous post, the New South Wales Geological Survey has been collecting geophysical data over the region. One measurement has been the intensity of magnetism (related to the iron content of rocks). Magnetic results can display what is happening under the earths surface, not just on top. It is known to show a characteristic feature where intrusions are known, either a strong negative or strong positive anomaly, depending on the rock type. The picture to the left shows the total magnetic intensity map (courtesy of the 2012 preliminary data package from the geological survey) for the area around Cabarita. I’m sure you can pick out the obvious red and blue anomaly. the pattern is consistent with intrusions, indeed exactly the same feature can be seen in the Mount Warning area (and others that I will discuss in future). As such, I suggest that this anomaly is actually good evidence of an intrusion hidden below the heat affected surface rocks. Smith (1999) thinks that the biotite grade metamorphism occurred during the Mesozoic period (well before the Cenozoic aged Lamington Volcanics) and that there was once a body of molten rock below the ground in this area.

I’m so pleased to be able to see the preliminary dataset, it is obvious that there are many features that can be better understood.


References/bibliography:

*Smith, J.V. 1999. Structure of the Beenleigh Block, northeastern New South Wales. New England Orogen: Regional Geology, Tectonics and Metallogenesis. Papers presented at a conference at the University of New England.
*Geological Survey of New South Wales. 2012. Grafton Tenterfield Airborne Geophysical Survey: Gridded and imagery data. Preliminary package from the Department of Trade and Investment: Resources and Energy.

Thursday, 26 July 2012

Why you won't find CSG here now

As you might have noticed there has been an occasional blog post that I’ve done dealing with coal seam gas matters in a cursory manner. I’ve been asked again and again by many people to explain aspects of the industry and the environmental issues associated with it. I’ve worked in coal exploration and in an environmental capacity before and I know a moderate amount about gas extraction too but I’m afraid I don’t have all the answers. Caution is needed especially given the highly political nature of the subject now. Therefore, I don’t really want to weigh into the subject, but I’ll have a very quick comment or two just to really outline the big picture. In the last week I cautiously commented in the Northern Star online twice as the avatar ‘GeologyRod’ just to correct a couple of mistakes people have made. I’ve also written one letter to the editor cautioning about how to interpret water chemistry. Given the heated debate, I’m not sure I will do so again!

From what I understand of the coal seam gas industry and the geology directly applicable to the area I am not as concerned about the industry doing damage to groundwater sources or surface water as some. From my contaminated land experience, I do however; see two potentially serious environmental problems. These are failure of well casings causing local cross-connection of poor and good quality water (and gas) and the disposal of poor quality production water (salinity is the biggest problem, as the chemicals potentially used can easily be treated but salt is hard to get rid of).

Considering a risk assessment approach (using the possible outcome and likelihood of that outcome) provides many scenarios with only the two mentioned above displaying an elevated level of risk (in my very hastily developed opinion). The nature of the geology of the southern Clarence-Moreton Basin is such that regional scale ground water contamination touted as a problem by many is probably of negligible risk, though this may occur elsewhere in eastern Australia in places like the Surat and Gunnedah Basins. However, local groundwater contamination (with a chance of affecting someone’s water supply bore) is probably on the moderate to high side. The disposal of salty water poses a moderate risk to the environment through adversely affecting large areas of pasture which might be irrigated or a moderate to high level if discharged untreated directly to fresh water streams.

Both of the matters outlined above are difficult to deal with and not knowing about the ins and outs of operators in the region I don’t know how the companies are going to mange these problems. This is ignorance on my part. I can only assume that this has been considered in detail (a legal requirement) so that the management of these problems is adequate.

This is my opinion only and given that opinions can get one in trouble I won’t be commenting on any other matters CSG related for quite some time. I really don’t like getting involved in political matters and it is easy to be carried into them. I hope I haven't been carried into them too far already. If you want to know a bit more about the technical side of coal seam gas extraction and the pollution risks there are some good fact sheets put out by the CSIRO linked to here. Maybe that is why I like rocks so much, they don’t argue with you (too much).

But back onto happier topics. I’ve been most excited by some new information that has come my way, one a University of New South Wales thesis by Leonary Drury on the Richmond Valley stratigraphy, groundwater, dating and much more, and the other is the preliminary geophysical data package released by the NSW geological survey. I’ll be blogging on these topics (plus others) in the coming months.

Monday, 23 July 2012

Geological diversity of the Toonumbar Dam area

Toonumbar Dam is a lovely area that, like so many other places, wish I could visit often. It would be lovely to relax around the dam, maybe stay the night camping or in a cabin. When I last visited, I was rather pathetic... I was looking at the rip-rap on the dam wall and trying to figure out where it was likely to have been quarried! I later found out and visited the quarry to obtain samples and look for structures. But that is a story for another day. As I was saying, the dam is a lovely place and like many beautiful places owes itself to the geological conditions of the area.

The oldest rocks (Mesozoic aged Clarence-Moreton Basin) exposed in the area are actually exposed downstream from the dam itself. Several hundred metres downstream are poor exposures of what appears to be rocks of the Jurassic Walloon Coal Measures, immediately downstream (and all around the dam) is the Kangaroo Creek Sandstone which is obvious to identify up close. The rocks which are apparently of the Walloon Coal Measures are a little harder to distinguish. It is possible that they are members of the MacLean Sandstone (which are considered part of the Walloon Coal Measures) or maybe Woodenbong Beds or even the underlying Bundamba Group but they are certainly younger than the Kangaroo Creek Sandstone.

Inclined bedding in Kangaroo Creek Sandstone
In Iron Pot Creek below the dam. Cross-bedding is also evident
It is worth noting the bedding plains in the sedimentary rocks if you are downstream of the dam. The plains are actually inclined to the west in this area and the further you go down stream the flatter the beds become, then they tilt back the other way (eastward) for a short distance. This is actually a large basin structure called the Toonumbar Anticline (the top of a fold in the rock layers). Another structure, much bigger and of regional significance is located only another couple of kilometres to the east. This is the East Richmond Fault which extends into southern Queensland and down almost to Grafton. I have actually never seen evidence of this fault in the field, but there is geophysical evidence for it and I'm assured it is there. Apparently the fault is much more evident further south between the villages of Mummelgum and Mallanganee.

The large rugged hill and ridge about 5km north of the dam is made from basalt lava, I'm not sure of the exact composition of this rock but it is likely to be part of the Kyogle Basalt which is associated with the Focal Peak Volcano. Interestingly, I think that the basalt is likely not to have been sourced from the actual peak of the volcano but from a distant vent on the side. This is because a few kilometres to the north west just on the north side of the lake is actually one of at least two intrusions of gabbro (the intrusive equivalent of basalt) near Toonumbar, one of these is crossed by Murrays Scrub Road. It is possible that these intrusions were the feeder systems for vents which erupted the Kyogle basalt in this area. This probably demonstrates the nature of volcanism in the area during the Cenozoic period. It seems apparent that the central volcano models of the Focal Peak and even the Tweed Volcanoes appears to be a bit too simplistic.

But, whether you are interested in geology or just enjoy the forests of the Northern Rivers, a trip to Toonumbar Dam is worth while.

Note that the stratigraphy of the Kangaroo Creek Sandstone has been revised since this blog post. See the this post for details.

References/Bibliography:

*O’Brien, P.E., Korsch, R.J., Wells, A.T., Sexton, M.J. Wake-Dyster, K. (1994) Structure and Tectonics of the Clarence-Morton Basin in Wells, A.T. and O'Brien, P.E. (eds.) Geology and Petroleum Potential of the Clarence-Moreton Basin, New South Wales and Queensland. Australian Geological Survey Organisation. Bulletin 241.
*Bell, A.D.M. (1968). Report on the geology of Toonumbar Dam and Appurtenant Works. Water Conservation and Irrigation Commission.

Sunday, 15 July 2012

Who has the answer? Woodenbong, MacLean, Grafton and a Kangaroo Creek

How well do we understand how the Clarence-Moreton Basin was formed? We know a little but not much about areas have never been drilled to understand the stratigraphy. A good example of our lack of geological understanding is the areas to the north and west of Kyogle, Bonalbo, Urbenville, etc. This area on the most recently published geological maps includes the area referred to as the Woodenbong Beds. We know very little about this particular formation.

It was actually Queensland based geologists (Exon et al. 1974) that first named the Woodenbong Beds. Exon et al (1974), (although according to the stratigraphic names database Coote (1986) is considered the first reference) described the lower portion of the Woodenbong Beds as massive to medium bedded pale-grey, fine to coarse grained, cross-bedded, labile (easily decomposed) sandstone. The upper portions were described as fine-medium grained feldspathic sandstone with siltstone, mudstone and minor coal. Stratigraphically, Exon et al (1974) also suggested that the Woodenbong Beds were lateral equivalents of the Kangaroo Creek Sandstone and/or the Grafton Formation. The boundary between the underlying Walloon Coal Measures was also described as conformable (that is, no significant time gap between deposition of the units).

Woodenbong beds possible stratigraphic relationships
Subsequent authors such as Wells & O'Brien (1994) have followed on with the definition provided by Exon et al (1974), who extrapolated the interpretation of the Woodenbong Beds to suggest that they may actually be equivalents of the Injune Creek Group (Springbok Sandstone and Westborne Formation) in the Surat Basin.

However, in the very same volume of work as Wells & O'Brien (1994) a different author, Willis (1994) proposed that the Woodenbong Beds actually underlie the Kangaroo Creek Sandstone (and therefore Grafton Formation), suggesting that the MacLean Sandstone Member of the Walloon Coal Measures was equivalent to the Woodenbong Beds. Willis (1994) also cited other authors such as (McElroy 1963, Ellice-Flint 1973 and Scott 1982 (note I have not seen these three publications)). These authors contradicted Exon et al 1974, and Wells & O'Brien 1994 by indicating that the boundary between the underlying Kangaroo Creek Sandstone is in places disconformable/unconformable (meaning there is a hiatus of deposition or a period of erosion preceding the formation of the Kangaroo Creek Sandstone).

The only thing all of the above authors agree on is that the composition of the Woodenbong Beds is very different from the Kangaroo Creek Sandstone and Grafton Formation. I'm sure you would agree that we obviously need more information to figure this one out!

Note that the stratigraphy of these formations have been recently revised since this blog post. See the this post for details.

References/Bibliography:

*Wells, A.T. and O'Brien, P.E. 1994. Lithostratigraphic framework of the Clarence-Moreton Basin. In Wells, A.T. and O'Brien, P.E. (eds.) Geology and Petroleum Potential of the Clarence-Moreton Basin, New South Wales and Queensland. Australian Geological Survey Organisation. Bulletin 241.
*Wells, A.T. and O'Brien, P.E. (eds.) 1994. Geology and Petroleum Potential of the Clarence-Moreton Basin, New South Wales and Queensland. Australian Geological Survey Organisation. Bulletin 241.
*Willis, I.L. 1994 Stratigraphic Implications of Regional Reconnaissance Observations in the Southern Clarence-Morton Basin, New South Wales In Wells, A.T. and O'Brien, P.E. (eds.) Geology and Petroleum Potential of the Clarence-Moreton Basin, New South Wales and Queensland. Australian Geological Survey Organisation. Bulletin 241.

see *Wells, A.T. and O'Brien, P.E. (eds.) 1994. Geology and Petroleum Potential of the Clarence-Moreton Basin, New South Wales and Queensland. Australian Geological Survey Organisation. Bulletin 241.  for other cited authors.

Sunday, 8 July 2012

The 'older' Rhyolite in the North East

In some of my earlier posts I mentioned that there are many areas in the mountains around the Tweed Valley that are comprised of rhyolite. I mentioned that this rhyolite was formed during eruptions associated with the Tweed Volcano during the Cenozoic era. This rhyolite is called the Nimbin Rhyolite or the Binna Burra Rhyolite (depending what side of the state border you are on). However, there is actually another large distribution of rhyolite not associated with the Tweed Volcano, erupting much earlier, during part of the Mesozoic known as the Triassic. These older mainly rhyolitic rocks are called the Chillingham Volcanics with the type location unsurprisingly located at Chillingham, a village west of Murwillimbah. Those of you who have seen my earlier posts will recognise that I have briefly mentioned the Chillingham Volcanics before, but in this post I intend to go into it further.

Layers of pyroclastics and volcaniclastic of the Chillingham Volcanics
(Murwillimbah - Kyogle Road)



The Chillingham Volcanics have been studied in a fair amount of detail by Roach (1997) in his thesis. This included all of the Triassic volcanic rocks from Brisbane to Uki. So, obviously there is a relationship with the rocks of the southern Queensland, Indeed Roach (1997) indicates that the Brisbane Tuff is a deposit of volcanic rock of rhyolitic composition. The Brisbane Tuff is most well known by the Kangaroo Point Cliffs opposite the Brisbane River in Brisbane City and was erupted during the same general period of time as the Chillingham Volcanics.

The Brisbane Tuff provides a miniature version of the Chillingham Volcanics and is well known because the volcanic centre can be identified in the northern suburbs of Brisbane and the tuff was laid down in the valleys that existed in the Palaeozoic aged basement. The situation which lead to the formation of the Brisbane Tuff also developed further west and south where a larger valley now known as the Ipswich Basin was forming. The eruptions occurred in and around the basin as the crust in this area was subsiding during thermal fluctuations and as the basin filled up with volcanic rocks subsidence continued leading to a very thick unit of mostly rhyolite and reworked volcanic rocks (actually a sedimentary rock known as a volcaniclastic rock). So the Chillingham Volcanics are actually the lower most stratigraphic unit in the Ipswich Basin.

The Chillingham volcanics are mainly comprised of rhyolite in the form of lavas, pyroclastic, ash and tuff deposits as well as the above mentioned volcaniclastics. Many volcanic vents are recognised from structural characteristics of the rocks, however, only one area really shows an obvious modern geomorphological character. This area is around Uki and Clarie Hall Dam where eruptions formed a large mass due to the slow moving nature of the lava. Interestingly the northern most parts of the Chillingham Volcanics in Queensland shows us that there was not just rhyolite but also some andesite and even basalt, but in the area between Chillingham and Uki it is pretty much all rhyolite.

Outcrops of the Chillingham volcanics occur over a long distance with the eastern most side of the Ipswich Basin exposed in New South Wales meaning that a band of the Chillingham Volcanics is visible within the eroded valleys of the Tweed Volcano. The band is actually interupted by the Mount Warning Complex which appears to have intruded right along the line of the pre-existing Chillingham Volcanics. Also the volcanics are covered by the Lamington Volcanics of the Tweed Volcano too, both along the Queensland Border and between Clarie Hall Dam and Evans Head. Indeed the Chillingham Volcanics appears to change composition through this area with authors such as Smith et al 1997 and Cotter 1998 identifying andestite and basalt at Evans Head and an area near Wardell.

The Chillingham Volcanics overlie palaeozoic aged rocks of the Beenleigh Block, mainly rocks of the Neranleigh-Fernvale Group. The overlying rocks are more components of the Ipswich Basin such as the Ipswich Coal Measures and its equivalent (such as the Evans Head Coal Measures).

Although I have said that the Chillingham Volcanics contain the older rhyolitic rock in this area, there are actually still older rhyolites in the region... But I'll talk about those rocks in a future post.

References/Bibliography:

*Cotter, S. 1998. A Geochemical, Palaeomagnetic and Geomorphological Investigation of the Tertiary Volcanic Sequence of North Eastern New South Wales. Masters Thesis, Southern Cross University.
*Roach, A. 1998. Late Triassic Volcanism of the Ipswich Basin, Masters Thesis, Macquarie University.
*Smith, J.V., Miyake, J., Houston, E.C. 1998. Mesozoic age for volcanic rocks at Evans Head, Northeastern New South Wales. Australian Journal of Earth Sciences V45